PolitiFact: Women’s pay-lag figure can be misapplied


On April 10, “Equal Pay Day,” Sen. Tina Smith, D-Minn., tweeted out her support for an end to differential pay for men and women.

But there’s a problem with her tweet: The statistics showing that women earn 80 percent of what men earn are overall comparisons and do not specifically compare men and women in the same jobs.

After we reached out to Smith’s office, she sent a new tweet to correct her earlier misstatement.

The most recent official data on this point, published by the U.S. Census Bureau, showed women earned 80.5 percent of what men did. That’s up by a couple percentage points in recent years.

However, as we’ve written previously, this figure actually refers to the general pay disparity, not comparing cases of apples to apples.

The 80 percent figure does not adjust for such factors as the degrees and jobs women pursue, the time they take off to care for children, the number of hours they work, and the years of experience they’ve had.

So while the 80 percent figure cannot be used to pinpoint pay discrimination between men and women doing the same work.

Other studies have shown a significantly closer match for men and women holding the same jobs. For instance, a 2013 study by the American Association of University Women found a 7 percent wage gap between men and women a year after graduating college.

Smith did have a point that women of color tend to fare more poorly on pay comparisons than do white women.

A 2014 report from the National Women’s Law Center concluded black women made 60 cents to the dollar earned by a white man, and Hispanic women made 55 cents.

Asian-American women earn higher wages than black and Hispanic men and women, as well as white women, Pew Research has found. Still, Asian-American women lagged behind white males for annual earnings.

Our ruling

Smith’s initial tweet said, “On average, American women only earn 80 cents for every dollar a man earns for doing the same job.”

The official federal data show that women earn 80 percent of what men earn, but that’s a collective average for all jobs, not a comparison of men and women holding identical jobs. For men and women holding the same job, there’s still a gap, but it’s substantially smaller.

Our policy is to acknowledge and applaud after-the-fact corrections by speakers we check, but we still put the original comment to the Truth-O-Meter. So Smith’s initial remark rates Mostly False.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in National

45 years ago today – Nixon’s “Saturday Night Massacre”
45 years ago today – Nixon’s “Saturday Night Massacre”

This Saturday marks the 45th anniversary of the infamous ‘Saturday Night Massacre,’ when an embattled President Richard Nixon fired the special Watergate prosecutor, but only after both the Attorney General and Deputy Attorney General refused to carry out the President’s orders, and resigned from their positions...
New York man arrested for threatening Senators over Kavanaugh
New York man arrested for threatening Senators over Kavanaugh

Federal prosecutors in New York announced the arrest on Friday of a man who allegedly threatened to murder and assault a pair of U.S. Senators for their support of Supreme Court Justice Brett Kavanaugh, as police say the suspect placed a series of threatening telephone calls in which the man threatened to shoot the Senators...
Trump praises GOP Congressman who assaulted reporter
Trump praises GOP Congressman who assaulted reporter

Attorney General Sessions hails “aggressive campaign against leaks”
Attorney General Sessions hails “aggressive campaign against leaks”

As a former FBI agent was sentenced to 4 years in prison Thursday in Minnesota for disclosing classified information to the news media, U.S. Attorney General Jeff Sessions hailed the latest court moves against leakers in the federal government, saying the Trump Administration is waging what may be ‘the most aggressive...
Trump urges immigration focus as he starts latest campaign swing
Trump urges immigration focus as he starts latest campaign swing

Expressing confidence in recent days about the impact of his work for GOP candidates in the 2018 mid-term elections for Congress, President Donald Trump starts a swing out west on Thursday to help Republican efforts to maintain control of the U.S. Senate, as he tries to make the issue of illegal immigration more central to the...
More Stories