Opinion: License to block people from getting work


Here is something that shouldn’t be controversial: People who want a job so they can improve their lives should be encouraged, not blocked by obstacles created by government.

Welcome to the hell, for many people, that is occupational licensing.

Some of the jobs to which lower-income Georgians might gravitate turn out to be some of the hardest to break into, requiring hundreds and hundreds of hours of training or experience before one can get a state-issued license. And the requirements can seem uneven and illogical across professions. Georgia prescribes 110 hours of training to become an emergency medical technician, tasked with saving people’s lives, but 1,000 hours to be a makeup artist.

“If you’re a young person wanting to get into the movie business, you might think, ‘Oh, I could be a makeup artist,’” says Rep. Buzz Brockway, R-Lawrenceville. “All right, fine — then, 1,000 hours later, then you can go apply for the license, then when you get one, you can go try to find a job.

“It seems a tad excessive.”

It doesn’t just seem that way. Georgia has the nation’s 14th most burdensome licensing laws, according to a review last fall by the Institute for Justice, a libertarian public-interest law firm. Our state doesn’t regulate all that many professions — just 41 of 102 lower-income occupations, according to the firm — but it regulates them onerously. Unfortunately, the trend is going in the wrong direction: In 2012, we ranked 18th.

It shouldn’t be that way. In 2010, legislators created a body to report on the licensing boards that in many cases set these regulations. (and which in many cases have an interest in limiting the number of people working in those industries, the better to limit their own competition). But, Brockway says, the Georgia Occupational Regulation Review Council has yet to submit one of the required reports to the Legislature.

“For some professions, maybe it makes sense,” Brockway allows. “But if no one’s reviewing it, how do we know? Is 1,500 hours of training really necessary for a barber? Maybe there’s compelling evidence to support that, but without these reviews we don’t know.”

“And it hurts the people on the lower end of the economic ladder who are trying to lift themselves out of poverty when there are regulations on those sorts of industries. Obviously, civil engineers and architects and those sorts of (jobs) need to be licensed. But it seems we have the most burdensome regulations on those that lower-income people could most easily get into otherwise.”

Brockway, who is running for secretary of state, the office that oversees many of these licensing boards, authored a resolution last year urging the council to do its job. It finally passed the House last month by a 161-0 vote.

“Generate these reports, give them to the Legislature, and let the Legislature determine what the policy should be,” Brockway says.

“In some cases, the Legislature has set those, requiring X number of continuing education credits. … Others it’s just (licensing) board policy, but the Legislature could override that if it found it was excessive. What blows my mind is the statistic that 50 years ago, 5 percent of the work force (nationally) required a license; you’re approaching 30 percent now.”

For all the talk of helping people get into jobs that don’t require college degrees, licensing remains an additional barrier. And, too often, an unnecessary one.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Voices

The problem with putting a number on Georgia's gang population
The problem with putting a number on Georgia's gang population

Every now and then, I will look up from the keyboard and suddenly realize that I’m in an argument. If you’re married, the same thing has probably happened to you once or twice. Some days ago, I focused on a joint press release on gang activity issued by Brian Kemp and Chris Carr, the Republican candidates for governor and attorney general...
Opinion: The shell game exposed
Opinion: The shell game exposed

In an internal poll leaked to Bloomberg News, the Republican National Committee bemoans the fact that the GOP tax cut is nowhere near as popular as Republicans had hoped, concluding that “we’ve lost the messaging battle on the issue.”  According to the survey, 61 percent of American voters believe that the GOP tax cuts were...
The Jolt: Dithering over SCOTUS pick could cost GOP the Senate, Reed warns
The Jolt: Dithering over SCOTUS pick could cost GOP the Senate, Reed warns

The transactional relationship between evangelicals and Republicans is on full display in Washington, as frustration grows among religious conservatives over Senate hesitation to confirm U.S. Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh. Warnings are being given, should Senate Republicans fail to deliver a high court justice who anti-abortion and pro-choice...
Abrams antes up with ‘community safety plan’ 
Abrams antes up with ‘community safety plan’ 

More community-oriented policing. Stricter enforcement of sex trafficking laws. Additional training for school resource officers. Democrat Stacey Abrams rolled out a “community safety plan” this week that leans toward preventing crimes before they happen to pair with her pledge to continue Gov. Nathan Deal’s criminal justice initiative...
Coming soon: The ‘Nathan Deal Judicial Center’ 
Coming soon: The ‘Nathan Deal Judicial Center’ 

A towering judicial complex that is one of the most expensive building projects in Georgia history could soon bear the name of the politician who has reshaped the state judiciary.  House Speaker David Ralston said this week at the State of the Ports gathering in Savannah that he’ll propose legislation next year that names the new ...
More Stories