Opinion: Term limits won’t solve the real problem


There’s a newcomer under the Gold Dome this year. He’s a polite fellow with a rather quixotic pursuit: Persuading state legislators to endorse a Constitutional Convention to create term limits.

Now, the idea isn’t to limit their own terms, but those for members of Congress. So, he’s having a bit of success. But while term limits are a popular idea, I’ve come to believe they’re the wrong prescription for the wrong disease.

“Career politicians” are easy to rail against. But in truth, not many people win and then occupy a single office for decades at a time. Oh, they might win a series of offices in a row, but that’s different — and not the kind of thing term limits would necessarily address.

The lack of staying power was evident this past week, as Republican and Democratic candidates for state or federal office in Georgia this year had to qualify for their races. Most incumbents signed their names and paid their qualifying fees to run again. The story was how many didn’t.

In the state House, 16 Republicans opted not to seek re-election. That might not sound like so many, out of 116 total House Republicans; it’s almost 14 percent. Of greater note, perhaps, was that 10 of the retirees are committee chairmen, posts coveted by lawmakers. They include the heads of the Education, Regulated Industries and both Judiciary committees, plum positions all.

If you’re still not convinced this represents significant change, or if you think it might be something of a one-off, consider this: Just 20 percent of House members have been in office more than 15 years, including most of the impending retirees. More than half were sworn into office within the last five years.

There’s much less movement from the Senate this year, but it was only in 2010 that we saw something of a mass exodus on that side of the building. As a result, only one in six senators have been in office more than 15 years. As in the House, half of our state senators have been in office five years or less.

People leave for all sorts of reasons. Some run for higher office. But for most others, the workload grows too large, the drives and time away from their family and real jobs too long (especially for South Georgia members), or their own age too high for them to want to continue. The pay, at about $17,000 per year, isn’t all that great, either. Taken together, these factors ensure what is supposed to be a temporary, part-time job as a citizen legislator remains just that for most.

Here, I need to make a confession. I began this column under the impression it was different in Washington. It is, but just barely.

In both the U.S. House and the U.S. Senate, the median member has been in office seven years — more than the five years in Georgia, but not by much. And only about a quarter of each chamber’s membership has been there more than 15 years.

So, back to term limits. Given that these offices already are turning over within a decade in most cases, what’s the real issue we ought to try to solve?

If it’s that lawmakers are too powerful, the antidote is to limit the scope of their power, not their time in office. If it’s that lawmakers, particularly in Washington, have become too insulated from the people they represent, the solution might be having them spend more time among their constituents and less time finding laws to tinker with, as we do in Georgia with our 40-day sessions each year.

In short, it’s not so much about limiting their number of terms, but what they do during the terms they do serve.


Reader Comments ...

Next Up in Voices

Georgia GOP lawmakers seek to expand on Trump’s border action
Georgia GOP lawmakers seek to expand on Trump’s border action

Georgia Republicans on Capitol Hill are aligning themselves with an executive order signed by President Donald Trump that reversed a contentious family separation policy on the southwest border. And many are urging Congress to take additional steps to bolster border security, improve conditions at federal detention centers and hire more immigration...
06/20 Mike Luckovich. Caged.
06/20 Mike Luckovich. Caged.

Georgia 2018: Kemp spends $1M for new round of ads  
Georgia 2018: Kemp spends $1M for new round of ads  

The GOP candidate for governor, whose provocative ads helped earn him a runoff date against Lt. Gov. Casey Cagle, has purchased $1 million worth of ads in the runup to the July 24 contest. The secretary of state’s campaign said he’s snapped up broadcast airtime in metro Atlanta and other major markets, along with Fox News spots statewide...
Torpy at Large: ‘Homes from the $500s!’ So, where do regular folks go?
Torpy at Large: ‘Homes from the $500s!’ So, where do regular folks go?

Robert Kee knew his intown Atlanta neighborhood had inordinately changed when he saw a jogger dragging some weights on wheels. “You could see the turn right there because no one would try that crap five years ago,” said the computer programmer who lives in Reynoldstown, a gentrifying neighborhood 3 miles east of downtown. Kee, who is white...
Opinion: GOP tattoos itself with Trump
Opinion: GOP tattoos itself with Trump

We have put very small-minded, small-hearted people in positions of very large responsibility and power.  All else that we witness today follows naturally and inevitably from that decision. And if you want it to stop, if this is not your idea of America, then you have to remove these small-minded, small-hearted people from power, through the voting...
More Stories